Wednesday, January 30, 2008

Should Huck Finn Be Taught in Schools?

Although the novel The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a classic, it is also a very controversial book. From my perspective, I believe that schools should teach this book, because it is a satirical novel addressing the characteristics of racism, realism and adventure. However, the language and the way these ideas are depicted in the novel can be seen as offensive and racist. Throughout the novel, Twain constantly refers to the “n” word and shows the character of Jim, the slave, as dim-lighted. However, I think Twain had no intention of using the “n” word to offend people. According to David Bradley, Twain was raised in a town where slavery existed and slaves were called by the “n” word. By using this word, which was commonly used during that time period, Twain depicts realism and reveals the certainty that this was how racism was and he is telling the truth. Throughout the novel, Huck struggles with racism and learns of Jim’s humanity and intelligence. He grows to realize that Jim is a person like him, but with a darker skin color. Like mother, Kathy Monteiro, I believe that students have the freedom to not read a book that offends them this much. Instead, I believe that in those schools, where great controversy rises, teachers should just make reading the book optional, outside of school. However, Huck Finn deserves to and should be taught in most schools. I don’t believe that Twain’s particular word choice was meant to offend anyone, but only demonstrate the actuality of racism. After all, the book is written in vernacular and the “n” word was then, a part of the common language. His word choice helps show that racism was existent to what extent. This classic novel regarding adventure, realism, racism and humor is not trying to offend anyone, but rather depict the reality of racism and a boy’s struggle and realization of what racism is.

1 comment:

Unknown said...

I find what you wrote to me most interesting i am actually writing a paper on this exact subject. You see in my mind i think that people who bann books are those who are to frightened to see what our past was like and too frightened to see anyone elses point of view. You see Huck Finn was written in a time when the people of our world spoke like that. the called people the "N" word all the time. It was their colture. We need to acnowelege that and know that this was just a book not a true story. If people get worked up aboout every little thing that they read then our would would constantaly be in an uproar. Banning books in a school is like banning sugar in an ice cream shop. Neither can be complete with out it. please pardon my spelling. In my Ap emglish class we have learned a few great saying like my personal favorite, If we dont know our past and learn from it then we are doomed to repeat it. And the last is that When you cant get information from one place you move on to the next, meaning that if your school banns the book then you read it by yourself. In my mind if you read it by yourself then all the questions you have cant be answered, if tought in school i think that teachers can help clarifi the book.

Gratsi

K